ANDOVER — A year ago, Dan Guinee had hopes of making the varsity football team as a sophomore, but a season long hamstring injury kept him on the shelf. He healed up and got ready for lacrosse season.

Tim Guinee was drawn to acting early. He studied at Houston's High School for the Performing and Visual Arts and has, since the mid-'80s, amassed many credits, including Sweet Land, an artful indie ...